Managing Risks as an Expert Witness
A Guide for Medical Professionals
Expert witness work can be both intellectually rewarding and financially lucrative. However, it is not without risks. This guide outlines key challenges expert witnesses may face and offers strategies to mitigate them.
Key Risks for Expert Witnesses
-
Criticism in Public Judgments
Experts may face scrutiny if their opinion falls outside their expertise, appears biased, or fails to meet legal standards. Public criticism can harm an expert’s professional reputation and online presence.
-
Professional Negligence Claims
Experts can be held legally accountable for negligent evidence. Opinions outside their expertise or unsupported by facts can lead to litigation, damaging both professional credibility and career prospects.
-
Third-Party Wasted Costs Orders (TPCO)
Courts can impose TPCOs on experts for improper, unreasonable, or negligent conduct. Such orders are rare but can significantly impact reputation, as they are often documented online.
-
Regulatory and Employment Issues
Unsatisfactory performance in court may result in referrals to regulatory bodies, fitness-to-practice proceedings, or even employment consequences.
Tips to Mitigate Risks
- Obtain Adequate Insurance: Ensure expert witness work is covered under professional indemnity policies.
- Stay Within Your Expertise: Decline cases that fall outside your professional scope.
- Maintain Comprehensive Records: Request and review all relevant case documents to ensure informed opinions.
- Offer Impartial Opinions: Provide objective insights on all factual scenarios to avoid appearing as an advocate.
- Seek Legal Advice: Act promptly if issues arise to minimize risks and safeguard your position.
By adhering to these best practices, expert witnesses can navigate the complexities of their role while safeguarding their professional reputation.